Fight Looms Over Legalizing Immigrant
Children Tue October 28,
2003 03:55 PM ET
By Alan Elsner, National
Correspondent
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A political battle is looming over a
bill that would allow tens of thousands of children of illegal
immigrants to the United States to gain legal status and
receive state aid for college education.
The Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors Act
passed the Senate Judiciary Committee last week by 16 votes to
3. But the legislation still faces stiff obstacles in the
House (of Representatives).
The issue could play in next year's presidential election,
when both parties intend to fight for the growing Latino vote.
Immigration experts said President Bush's support would
greatly enhance the legislation's chances of being enacted. So
far, the White House has been noncommittal .
"We feel the White House will be supportive if we
demonstrate that the bill has enough support in the House to
stand a chance of being enacted," said Brent Wilkes, executive
director of the League of United Latin American Citizens.
The bill, sponsored by Utah Republican Sen. Orrin Hatch and
Illinois Democrat Richard Durbin, would grant conditional
permanent resident status to young people who came to the
United States illegally with their parents.
To be eligible, they would have to have been in the country
for five years at the time of the bill's enactment, have
entered before the age of 16, have graduated from high school
and have a clean record. They would have the chance to qualify
for permanent residency by completing two years of college or
by serving for two years in the armed services within the next
six years.
The bill would also repeal part of immigration legislation
passed in 1996 that banned states from offering college
tuition grants or aid to illegal immigrants.
"Many youngsters find themselves in a Catch-22 situation.
As illegal immigrants, they cannot work legally. Moreover,
they are effectively barred from developing academically
beyond high school," said Hatch, introducing the bill. "Though
these children have built their lives here, they have no
possibility of achieving or living the American dream."
YOUNG MAN DEPORTED
Last August, the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled
that a 24-year-old Guatemalan had to be deported, even though
he had lived in the United States since arriving illegally
with his mother when he was less than a year old.
It is unclear exactly how many people would be affected by
the bill. According to lawyer Greg Siskind, who puts out a
weekly newsletter on immigration law, as many as 65,000
illegal immigrants graduate from U.S. high schools every year
but not all would meet the conditions of the bill.
Wilkes said perhaps 100,000 could benefit immediately.
But opposition is already gathering. Groups opposing any
amnesty for illegal immigrants argue that the legislation
would merely reward illegal behavior.
"It's a slap in the face to legal immigrants who play by
the rules. Sure, it puts a more attractive face on amnesty
because these people came here as children with their parents.
But it still rewards illegal immigration," said Steve Camarota
of the Center for Immigration Studies, a group which supports
slowing the flow of immigration to the United States.
All three senators who voted against the act in committee
last week were Republicans from the South, where Bush has his
strongest support.
|