Churches
Education
Elected Officials
Golf Courses
Hunting & Fishing
Libraries
Local Media
Parks
Performing Arts
Places to go
Post Offices
Senior Services
Services









Immigrant workers want 'out of the shadows'

By Erin Sullivan
Contact

January 9, 2004

Javier Anaya has lived in the shadows more than half his life.

He was 13 when his mother called for him to join her in California. She had left Mexico City - for more money and bigger and better dreams - the year before in 1990.

Anaya rode a bus to the border. A van was waiting for him in California. His mother was inside. It was dark and he was scared, but they made it.

Anaya and his mother moved to Memphis in 1997 to be with family. She works odd jobs with a temp agency - cleaning houses, working in factories. Anaya, who quit school after the eighth grade, works in construction and as a car mechanic.

They live quiet lives in the shadows with hundreds if not thousands of other illegal immigrants in the Memphis Metro area.

"Mostly, people are scared," said Anaya, 27.

"That's why they don't call police."

People like Anaya and his mother are called illegal aliens by some, undocumented immigrants by the politically correct. Attorneys and others who work with these immigrants say most of them are scared to be seen or heard for fear of deportation. And gaining legal status is nearly impossible.

But some local experts say President Bush's new immigration proposal might help people like Anaya and his mother gain legal status - if only temporarily.

The proposal would create a "temporary worker program" for the estimated 8 million undocumented immigrants living in the United States. "Guest worker" status would last three years. It is not clear whether extensions would be granted. Immigrants would have to find employers to sponsor them.

"This proposal takes people out of the shadows," said immigration attorney Greg Siskind of Memphis.

"You feel like a fugitive when you are operating without (legal) status. (Illegal immigrants) don't want to report crimes. They don't want to be a part of society . . . .

"This doesn't go toward solving the problem of illegal immigration, but it does bring common sense to the system."

Some disagree.

"The biggest problem with the proposal is that it's not made clear whether there will be a realistic path to permanent legal residency," said David Lubell of Nashville, state coordinator of the Tennessee Immigrant and Refugee Rights Coalition.

"We could end up with a system that has a lot of potential for abuse. A system that puts temporary workers at the mercy of their employers because those workers are dependent on those employers for their legal status."

Anaya thinks fear of deportation will keep illegals in the shadows, regardless of Bush's proposal.

But others say fear will do the opposite.

"This way they could work more and they can feel more comfortable - if they have to go to the doctor, to school, whatever," said Hector Mendoza, editor of La Prensa Latina who came to the United States from Mexico in 1999.

"It is a hard life without legal status. . . . They are afraid to be here, but they want to work."

Jose Chavez not only wants to work, he wants to become an American citizen.

He and his wife, Maria, left their home in Chihuahua, Mexico, in 1996 and came to Memphis. During the next three years, their five children left Mexico and joined them here. They crossed the Rio Grande on the Texas border with their passports, but they didn't have work visas.

Jose and Maria work nearly 60 hours a week painting houses. The children paint on the weekends. The family is working with Siskind Susser Immigration Lawyers to obtain permanent status here.

Jose has a work visa. His wife and children are undocumented.

"It is very hard because you always live with this fear," he said through an interpreter.

"It is a great sacrifice because when you leave Mexico, you leave everything behind. You don't have peace. You are always afraid. You live afraid."

Jose, who has bought a house in Raleigh, said Bush's proposal would be wonderful.

"I think it would be a great relief to my countrymen, because you will work with more energy because you know nobody is going to come and take you away from your job," he said.

- Erin Sullivan: 529-5880

Get a new lease on lifegomemphisautos.comSee today's Commercial Appeal display adsgomemphiscareers.comDownload and print couponsSearch the CA ClassifiedsGreat local restaurants and nightspotsgomemphis PersonalsResidential - Commercial - AgentsTravel dealsInformation for potential advertisers

Site Extras

Site Extras

Copyright 2004 - The Commercial Appeal is an E.W. Scripps Company newspaper.
Other E.W. Scripps sites: HGTV | Food Network | Do It Yourself | Fine Living
commercialappeal.com traffic is audited by the Audit Bureau of Circulations. View our latest audit results.

User agreement | Privacy statement | E-mail Webmaster | Amplifications & corrections | Make commercialappeal.com your home page | Commercial printing | Job opportunities | Newspapers in Education | Sunday Early Edition Locations