Best Lawyers in Nashville
by David A. Fox

January, 2003 — Choosing a lawyer is not as simple as selecting an architect—“Hey, I like that house. Who’s the architect?” Or as statistically straightforward as a baseball team owner studying players’ slugging percentages to find a new power hitter.

No, ascertaining the abilities of attorneys is a difficult business. First, the services lawyers perform usually do not lend themselves to scientific measurement. Second, whatever potentially meaningful scores are out there—perhaps the win-loss ratio of courtroom litigators—have not been compiled. And third, much of what lawyers do they do quietly, out of earshot. So there really are no useful legal industry counterparts to the Daily Racing Form.

At best, all you can do is ask other lawyers whom they would use if they were in a particular jam. Maybe you also could ask any judges or prosecutors you happen to know which lawyers appear to be the best from their a vantage point. And you could always seek out the opinions of friends who have retained the services of one barrister or another.

To save you the trouble, that’s what Nashville Post has been doing the past few months. Adding to our existing knowledge of the local lawyer community is wisdom gleaned from many dozens of interviews with the cognoscenti of our legal scene.

The result is a user-friendly guide for anyone needing to find the right lawyer to handle problems in any of 32 categories of legal practice, such as white-collar defense, bankruptcy, trusts and estates, and collections. Many are not well-known names—our watchword was “results triumph over reputation”—and certainly, not all of Nashville’s top lawyers are on our list (and none who are not taking new clients). Needless to say, an attorney’s inclusion on the list does not ensure that he or she is the ideal lawyer for you.

But it does mean that the 100 lawyers on the following pages have been rigorously vetted by the people who see their work first-hand. All are worthy of recognition as belonging among the Best Lawyers in Nashville 2003.

Banking

Katie Edge --Miller & Martin
Former deputy commissioner and general counsel of the state Department of Financial Institutions, which has left her with very good relations with regulators. Known for being “a facilitator,” “very caring and understanding of the banker’s side of things.” Good at “hand-holding” anxious bank clients. Has worked many deals as a partner at Miller & Martin and recently ranked as one of the busiest banking M&A firms in the country. A past president of Tennessee Bar Association.

Steve Eisen -- Baker, Donelson, Bearman & Caldwell
Maintains the largest banking practice in Tennessee, representing more than 100 community banks here and in surrounding states, including half of the 30 banks on Tennessee’s “watch list.” Along with others at Baker, is very active in working with de novo banks. He’s “your person for knowing the rules and regulations.” Chairman of the Tennessee Bankers Association’s (lawyers committee) and member of government relations committee. Author of numerous banking articles.

Frank McCreary -- Gerrish & McCreary
Brings 25-year banking industry experience to bear in legal practice. Was general counsel for First American Corp. (1971-1981), president and chief operating officer of $1.2 billion-in-assets Metropolitan Federal Bank (1988-1991). Knows the “inter-twining of bank operations and issues, so he knows best what to ask.” Former chairman of the bank lawyers committee of the Tennessee Bankers Association. Also an accomplished mediator in U.S. District Court and Rule-31 mediator in Tennessee.

Mary Neil Price -- Miller & Martin
Was general counsel of $20.7 billion-in-assets First American Corp. until its sale to AmSouth. Oversaw 12-person legal staff at First American. Was responsible for SEC reporting, corporate governance, compliance, and regulatory relations, among other areas. Was a partner at Dearborn & Ewing prior to bank industry work. “Has wide experience in banking and sophisticated corporate matters.” A partner in Miller & Martin’s active banking practice.

Bob Thompson -- Bass, Berry & Sims
Twenty-seven year veteran of Tennessee’s banking industry as a Bass, Berry & Sims attorney. The “most seasoned” of all lawyers working with public and smaller community banks. A “philosophical analyzer” great at creating legal theories for bank regulators (who can seem as important to the process as the laws themselves). Influential in drafting state legislation affecting banks and other financial institutions. Active in American Bar Association committees. Harvard Law graduate.

Bankruptcy

Larry Ahern -- Greenebaum, Doll & McDonald
Experienced, highly regarded creditor’s lawyer. Recently moved to Greenebaum from Gullet Sanford. Fellow of the American College of|*ñ Bankruptcy. Has co-authored several West law books, including Bankruptcy Procedure Manual (4th ed.), Bankruptcy Jury Manual (4th ed.), and Bankruptcy Execution Manual. Director of the American Board of Certification since 1998. President of the Tennessee chapter of the Turnaround Management Association.

Rhea Bucy -- Gullet, Sanford, Robinson & Martin
Arguably the best debtor’s attorney in the state. Was most successful in the ’80s and ’90s in cramming down lenders to troubled, single-asset, real estate deals. Currently chairs the Tennessee Bar Association’s commercial bankruptcy and banking section. Took part in helping Sixth Circuit Judicial Council recommend candidates to fill two federal bankruptcy judgeships in Middle Tennessee. Past chair of Nashville Bar Association’s bankruptcy court committee.

Craig Gabbert -- Harwell, Howard, Hyne, Gabbert & Manner
Regularly in the middle of the city’s largest Chapter 11 cases, frequently representing the debtors, as in last year’s filing by Brentwood-based Pen Holdings. Participated in the rehabilitation plan of Xantus Healthplan in 1999 and the bankruptcies of Regal Cinemas, Nu-Kote Holdings, Service Merchandise, Access Health Systems, Washington Industries and Vendell Healthcare. Barrister at the Harry Phillips Inn of Court, a group of Nashville attorneys who meet to improve their skills.

Hank Hildebrand -- Lassiter, Tidwell & Hildebrand
Foremost local and nationally recognized expert on Chapter 13 bankruptcy, which lets individuals rearrange their financial affairs, repaying debts over several years via a bankruptcy trustee. Has been standing trustee for Chapter 13 in Middle Tennessee for 20 years. “A machine—he really cranks it out.” Speaks across the country, including before congressional committees, on consumer bankruptcy issues. “If you have a problem, Hank can solve it.”

Jim Kelley -- Neal & Harwell
Very active practice representing creditors, usually banks, led by Bank of America. Local counsel for group of banks in the American HomePatient bankruptcy. Has an advantage in having a Masters in Tax. Also, a go-to guy for corporate and individual “workouts,” agreements from lenders to accept less, rather than push for bankruptcy. “If I’m a high net worth person with problems, he’s the person I would call.” A Fellow in American College of Bankruptcy.

Marc McNamee -- Neal & Harwell
Some debtor work, but has distinguished himself representing institutional lenders. Past chairman of the Nashville Bar Association’s bankruptcy court committee. Was a director of the Mid-South Commercial Law Institute, 1994-1999. Along with other Neal & Harwell attorneys, was counsel to Texas Boot in its reorganization last year involving The Bank of Nashville and Sunrock Capital in refinancing $10 million of debt. Has represented Texas-based wholesale bank Beal Bank.

William Norton III -- Boult, Cummings, Conners & Berry
One of the first local lawyers mentioned in any discussion of bankruptcy. So savvy in the field, you’d think his father wrote the book on bankruptcy, which he did. Former U.S. bankruptcy Judge William Norton Jr. heads Norton Institutes on Bankruptcy Law, where Bill III is managing editor of Norton Bankruptcy Law and Practice 2d, the 12-volume treatise published by West Group. Board member of American Board of Certification, certifying attorneys in creditor rights and bankruptcy law.

Charles Reasor Jr. -- White & Reasor
A workout pro in tough times, a commercial real estate pro in good times. Well-known in legal industry for quietly resolving debt disputes. “We try to keep it hush-hush,” he says. “Charlie’s very good at finding a middle ground,” which is essential if bankruptcy filings are to be avoided. Represented (with great effort, though falling short of achieving a decent agreement) the Freeman real estate family in the spectacular collapse of their real estate syndication empire in late 1980s.

Business Litigation

Jay Bowen -- Bowen, Riley, Warnock & Jacobson
Active in Music Row litigation. Clients include Sony, AOL Time Warner, BMG and Mike Curb. Intellectual property/copyright work led to his chairing American Bar Association’s subcommittee on the manufacture and sale of counterfeit copies of audiovisual works and sound recordings. Defended Shawn Mullins in copyright infringement suit on “Everywhere I Go,” Joe Diffie in “Prop Me Up Beside the Jukebox,” and Curb Records in LeAnn Rimes’ bid to end her contract.

Sam Lipshie -- Boult, Cummings, Conners & Berry
Reputation as one of the toughest litigators in town. Strong-willed, “to the point of being mean,” but frequently successful. Often involved in copyright infringement disputes. Represented Miramax Films in settling complaints by R&B legend George Clinton stemming from song sampling. Filed $10 million suit for Roy Orbison’s widow, Barbara, against documentary production company. Defended ex-manager of ProTours against litigation brought by The Judds.

Steve Riley -- Bowen, Riley, Warnock & Jacobson
Aggressive litigator, specializing in complex cases. Counsel to HCA in its investigation by Medicare and in shareholder lawsuits. Counsel to Bridgestone in its tire-related lawsuits. Busiest in securities and health care related litigation, often defending against qui tam actions. Involved in the J.C. Bradford class action. Has represented Stephens of Little Rock, Ark. Was involved in the Alvin Beaman estate dispute. Represented renal care giant Fresenius in non-compete matters.

Bob Walker -- Walker, Bryant, Tipps & Malone
Has had an active role in most major corporate lawsuits here for the past 30 years, from representing the buyers of the Nashville Banner in an early-’80s dispute with then-partner John Jay Hooker, to more recent class-action suits involving CCA, Sirrom and HCA. Monterey, Tenn., native “gets down on the common man’s level” to sway juries. Agile mind and business acumen impress top business execs. “No one approaches him here in sheer knowledge.” Active in medical malpractice defense.

Civil Rights

George Barrett -- Barrett, Johnston & Parsley
Best known today as the Nashville connection for securities class-action firm Milberg Weiss. But most highly regarded for civil rights and labor work. Original counsel for 1969 lawsuit seeking to change state’s public education. In 1960s and 1970s, took part in civil rights commissions. Attorney in Oak Ridge radioactivity lawsuit filed in 2001. Co-counsel on $10 million Vanderbilt settlement stemming from 1940s experiments on women. Represented plaintiffs in class actions against Bridgestone, HCA, CCA.

Richard Dinkins -- Dodson, Parker, Dinkins & Behm
Carries legacy of local civil rights crusaders Avon Williams and Alexander Looby. Involved in 1998 resolution of Metro desegregation case and $250 million improvement plan. Represented TSU professors in the higher education desegregation lawsuit. One of several attorneys to file suit two years ago about possible health effects of radioactive contamination on a largely African-American population. Has represented Abu-Ali Abdur’Rahman. Cooperating attorney with NAACP Legal Defense Fund.

Collections

John Cheadle -- Cheadle & Cheadle
Dominates corporate collections in Middle Tennessee. The Vanderbilt Law graduate “is a machine that churns out collections.” Focuses his attention on banks—represents Bank of America, Union Planters, SunTrust. “John is very, very good.” Also performs other commercial litigation services for banks. Holds a pilots license and handles aviation cases. Has a small specialty in receivership law and was receiver of Donelson Plaza Shopping Center, the Gallatin Group Inc.

Art Lowen -- Solo practice
Has three-quarters of the collections business in Nashville-area condominium and homeowners association market. Works with property managers Ghertner & Co., Timmons Properties, Cadwallader Enterprises, Association Management Services, Community Management Affiliates. Does most of Edwin B. Raskin Co.’s collections from residential and commercial tenants. Litigates commission disputes. Performs related services: lien foreclosures, property document revisions.

Constitutional

Jim Blumstein -- Faculty, Vanderbilt School of Law
Preeminent constitutional theorist, "top-flight" constitutional appellate advocate. Involved in five successful U.S. Supreme Court cases, arguing two: the early 1970s challenge of the constitutionality of a length-of-residency requirement for vote4 registration and 2000 argument for Brentwood Academy in TSSAA dispute. " Most knowledgeable on constitutionality, health care and the future of health care." Directs the Health Policy Center at the Vanderbilt Institute of Publis Policy Studies.

Corporate

Andree Blumstein -- Sherrard & Roe
Without peer locally in writing state and federal appellate briefs. “Her writing is a joy to read.” A “remarkable intellect,” with a Ph.D. in Germanic languages and literature from Yale. Adept at contract negotiations and drafting. Special interest in antitrust, state tax law and health law. On the editorial board of the Tennessee Bar Journal. “I’ve never seen her nonplussed.” A member of the National Health Lawyers Association. “Can craft a flawless brief on any litigation issue.”

Howard Lamar -- Bass, Berry & Sims
At 41 years of age, one of the youngest on the list. “A securities law star.” Has a busy, thriving corporate practice, assisted by pre-law school experience as a loan officer with a Bank of America predecessor. Engaged in some of the larger, and thorniest, corporate matters in town, including representing Dollar General Corp. “Very good” transactional lawyer. Active in venture capital financings. Represents Bright Horizons Family Solutions.

Tom Sherrard -- Sherrard & Roe
“The best in town at transactional law.” Has the “intellectual grounding for a broad range of corporate activities.” Teaches “financial instruments” class to Vanderbilt law and business students. “Non-confrontational” demeanor well suited to transactional practice. Numerous civic involvements, ample powerful contacts. Member of American Bar Association’s committees on federal securities law and commercial law. Often aided by associate Allen Roberts, who also gets great reviews.

Andy Smith -- Bass, Berry & Sims
“Probably the best young lawyer at Bass, Berry & Sims.” Strong suit is difficult corporate finance matters. A director of the Tennessee Business Roundtable. “Could be a wise counselor to any business.” Recently represented American Retirement Corp. in an extremely complex refinancing and balance sheet restructuring. “Very hard working.” Not as well known as some, but highly skilled, an “up-and comer” among top-tier corporate attorneys here.

Leigh Walton -- Bass, Berry & Sims
Active transactional attorney, especially in health care. Represented Children’s Comprehensive Services in its $70 million sale. Represented Ingram Entertainment in its $43 million acquisition of video rental company Major Video in 2000. Served health care companies Iasis and PrincipalCare in venture capital stage. On American Bar Association’s corporate laws and negotiated acquisitions committees. Member of American Health Lawyers Association.

Defense Litigation (Criminal)

Richard Braun -- Braun & Crotswell
Fourteen years as an antitrust attorney for U.S. Dept. of Justice in Chicago. Involved in Blanton-era bid-rigging prosecutions. Now well regarded for white-collar defense work, especially concerning tax problems. “A different caliber” litigator than normally found here. Also attended London School of Economics. Spends much time in federal courts. Argued Vanderbilt philosophy instructor Idit Dobbs-Weinstein’s tenure-dispute case before the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals.

Jim Neal -- Neal & Harwell
Most acclaimed trial lawyer in state, among top echelon in the country. Less active now at 73, but still takes engagements from those in need of superlative defense (at a premium price). Prosecuted Jimmy Hoffa while special assistant to Attorney General Robert Kennedy. Was chief Watergate prosecutor and U.S. Attorney for Middle Tennessee. Defended Exxon in Valdez spill, Ford in the case of the exploding Pintos. Partner Aubrey Harwell shoulders big load, honing the art of quieter dispute resolutions.

Charles Ray -- Ray & Frensley
Defender of “crimes in the streets, as opposed to crimes in the suites.” Works courts from Davidson County General Sessions to U.S. Supreme Court. Got a “not guilty” for B.G. Vanhooser, liquor store clerk charged with murdering driver of robber’s alleged getaway car. Successfully defended a floor finisher who shot a plumber in Green Hills. Argued U.S. Supreme Court case on immunity of CCA prison guards. “Excellent defense lawyer.” Vanderbilt Law graduate.

Jimmy Sanders -- Neal & Harwell
The first name mentioned by most when asked for Nashville’s best criminal defense attorney. Practiced with legendary Neal since 1978. Tries cases all over the nation. Defended director John Landis in “Twilight Zone” case and Exxon in Valdez spill. Also active in civil litigation. Was counsel to Bridgestone/Firestone in tire lawsuit. Represents Ingram Industries, Morgan Stanley Dean Witter, Qwest Communications. Was a trial attorney on felonies for Seattle public defenders office 1975-1977.

Ed Yarbrough -- Hollins, Wagster & Yarbrough
The first call Nashville’s elite make when they have criminal problems. Vietnam vet, former assistant D.A. Represented state Sen. Doug Jackson against charges of abuse against 16-year-old daughter. Led efforts by three of Tammy Wynette’s daughters in $50 million wrongful death lawsuit against physician. Defended singer George Jones on reckless driving charges. Got a 30-day sentence for Azerbaijani immigrant who threw a knife, killing his wife.

Defense Litigation (White Collar)

John S. Bryant -- Walker, Bryant, Tipps & Malone
Very experienced, “solid” trial lawyer, with more than 40 jury cases tried to verdict in past 29 years. Focused on defending claims of product liability and professional negligence, frequently in health care. “Very smart and very cautious.” Member of Tennessee Society of Hospital Attorneys. Has defended numerous environmental actions: contamination of Memphis trash dump, groundwater contamination in Jackson, Tenn. “Capable of trying all types of civil defense cases well.”

Jim Doran -- Waller, Lansden, Dortch & Davis
Long regarded among top product liability defense attorneys. Also active in toxic torts and professional liability. A past director of the Defense Counsel Trial Academy at the International Association of Defense Counsel. Product liability work aided by undergraduate education at Tennessee Tech. Has authored several amicus curiae (friend of the court) briefs in Tennessee and U.S. Supreme Courts. Assisted rewriting of state’s pattern jury instruction for civil cases.

Gayle Malone -- Walker, Bryant, Tipps & Malone
Civil trial lawyer since 1973. Frequently represents hospitals in lawsuits, though also represents plaintiffs in claims against hospitals. Member of American Academy of Hospital Attorneys and the International Association of Defense Counsel. Active practice representing Tennessee hospitals in medical staff matters and certificate of need litigation. Representation spans plaintiffs and defendants in medical malpractice, motor vehicle actions, premises and product liability.

Divorce

Robert L. “Bobby”Jackson -- Jackson, Kweller, Moore, Warden & Hayes
Saw the opportunities in domestic law while working for Judge Benson Trimble during college and law school at Vanderbilt. Began practicing in 1965, but only since 1990 has he focused exclusively on domestic law. Practice nearly evenly divided between male and female clients. After a 14-month impasse, was called in to mediate the divorce ending the 17-year marriage of Vince and Janis Gill—the Gills, Janis’ lawyer Rose Palermo, Vince’s lawyer Lew Conner, and Jackson resolved it in one day.

Jim Martin -- Stites & Harbison
The reflexive response of males when asked to identify the divorce attorney they would use, though he does represent men and women. Began focusing on domestic relations—divorce, child custody, child support—in 1990. Lectures on domestic law matters. Member of the Domestic Relations Code Commission. Represented Nashville Banner Publisher Irby Simpkins in his 2000 divorce from Peaches Simpkins. Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers.

Rose Palermo -- Cheatham & Palermo
Divorce lawyer to the country music stars. Widely respected for her skills, feared by some due to big successes, usually representing women. An exception: was counsel to Sammy Kershaw in his divorce. Represented Wynonna in her split from Arch Kelley, Janis Gill from Vince, Kristyn Osborn of Shedaisy in a divorce last year. Provides some services other than divorce, such as representing the executor of the Conway Twitty estate. Music Row office. Vanderbilt Law School graduate.

DUI

John M.L. Brown -- Brown & Fusner
More of a police defender and child custody attorney than a drunk driving specialist, but his DUI skills are held in high regard by area attorneys. Well-trained gun enthusiast and instructor, stays on call on behalf of the Fraternal Order of Police to visit scene of officer-related shootings. Represents officers who are subjects of excessive force claims. Represented the father in a custody battle involving client’s ex-wife and the actual biological father of his children.

V. Michael Fox -- Bruce, Weathers, Corley & Lyle
“DUI MIKE”—the high-profile, bathroom-advertising face of drunk driving defense in Middle Tennessee. Has earned respect from those who have seen him practice. “Very knowledgeable on the subject of DUI.” Board Certified by the National College of DUI Defense, of which Fox is a founding member. Booming practice, six years after adopting use of Graffiti Indoor Advertising’s restroom posters, supported by radio spots. Also defends against vehicular assault and homicide charges.

Entertainment

Orville Almon -- Zumwalt, Almon & Hayes
Not the flashiest or highest profile entertainment attorney in town, less even than partner Jim Zumwalt, but “exceptionally talented and experienced.” The native of Cairo, Ill., has tight relationships with record label staffers who draft agreements. “Best technical drafts-person in town.” Known for being honest, to the point of letting other side know of mistakes in their drafts. Was a captain in the U.S. Army. Member of the Country Music Association.

Ken Kraus -- Loeb & Loeb
A Los Angeles transplant who manages the L.A.-based firm’s Nashville office. Shares with Milom “senior status” among local entertainment lawyers. Huge clients and big deals. Handled all negotiations for the Elvis Lives one-hour TV special on NBC during Thanksgiving and for the Elvis: 30 #1 Hits LP. In addition to the estate of “The King,” represents The Wallflowers, Clint Black, Kid Rock, Amy Grant, Steven Curtis Chapman and Nickel Creek.

Mike Milom -- Bass, Berry & Sims
The biggest name in entertainment law in Music City. “Understands the art of the deal better than anyone.” Client roster includes Hank Williams Jr., Brooks & Dunn, Trick Pony and Alabama. “Classic, old school lawyer with a grasp of modern technology.” National reputation in intellectual property law. “Sees through the minutia to get deals done.” Founding director of the Copyright Society of the South. On ABA’s Copyright Office Committee of intellectual property.

Environmental

James Weaver -- Waller, Lansden, Dortch & Davis
“Probably the broadest experience with environmental law and issues.” Known for expertise on river crossing issues and ARAP, the state’s Aquatic Resource Alteration Permit program. Tennessee editor of Matthew Bender’s Brownfields Law and Practice. Lead counsel in permitting for pipelines, power plants, mines. Represented “responsible parties” at more than 40 Superfund sites, but like Bass’ Drew Goddard who has done even more Superfund work, currently has few such projects here.

Family Law

Bob Tuke -- Tauger, Ney & Tuke
A superlative adoption lawyer who has represented hundreds of parents, in addition to his corporate practice. Current president of the American Academy of Adoption Attorneys. Author of the adoption chapter in West’s Tennessee Practice (2nd Ed., 2002). Helped draft 1996 revision of state adoption laws. Board member of Nashville’s Family and Children’s Services. Father of two college-age adopted children. Marine veteran of Vietnam, awarded Cross of Gallantry in combat.

First Amendment

Al Knight -- Willis & Knight
Longtime lead First Amendment attorney for The Tennessean. Expert on suing to enforce Tennessee Public Records Act. Argued for media access to NES customer information. Challenged sealing of settlement between Lebanon and a private citizen. Led Tennessean efforts to open files on Kirby Pines Estates in 1996 Sundquist campaign controversy. Defended against inmate’s defamation charge where court found lifetime incarceration “renders any reputation he may have had virtually valueless.”

Doug Pierce -- King & Ballow
Since 1988, has been counsel to the Tennessee Association of Broadcasters, which includes radio and television stations. General counsel to Nashville Federation of Advertisers. Prepared “The Door to Open Government in Tennessee” handbook for the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press. Defends media against charges of violating state’s Personal Rights Protection Act. Argued for media access to Chattanooga Police reports of auto accidents.

Bill Willis -- Willis & Knight
In addition to leading First Amendment work, one of city’s best general civil defense litigators. Has forcefully argued for intervenors The Tennessean and Society of Professional Journalists to gain access to discovery materials in lawsuits. Former chairman of Board of Professional Responsibility. Active health care litigation practice, including representing Memorial Hospital in sale to HealthTrust. Chief negotiator for Nashville School of Law’s efforts to merge with TSU.

Health Care (Regulatory)

Dan Elrod -- Miller & Martin
Focuses on state-level regulation of health care facilities. Has represented the Tennessee Hospital Association on exclusive physician contracting. Active in certificate of need (CON) disputes, argued for an East Tennessee nursing home opposing CON for new competitor. Represented The Blakeford at Green Hills in state regulatory matter. Lobbies on behalf of hospitals and insurers in the Tennessee General Assembly. Administrator of Tennessee Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Association.

Debbie Larios -- Waller, Lansden, Dortch & Davis
Foremost authority on health care regulations. Applies experience from nine years working in the Medicaid programs of New York and Tennessee before earning law degree in 1988. Expert on HIPAA, Stark II physician self-referral laws, payor liability, and broadly on issues of Medicare fraud and abuse. Writes and speaks in national forums on regulatory matters. Co-chair of American Bar Association’s health law section’s committee on e-health and privacy.

Health Care (Transactional)

Steve Braun -- Greenebaum, Doll & McDonald
Gained valuable first-hand experience with very large health care transactions as general counsel and senior vice president of Columbia/HCA from 1991 to 1997. Has negotiated numerous acquisitions and divestitures of hospitals and other facilities. Oversaw the securities work on five $1 billion-plus transactions. Recognized in 1996 by Corporate Counsel as one of the nation’s “Forty-five under 45.” Experience implementing complex stock-based compensation programs.

Mike Brent -- Boult, Cummings, Conners & Berry
Dominates the legal niche serving long-term care companies and their lenders. Mostly transactional work. Thoroughly understands the economics and regulatory framework for nursing home and other post-acute care providers. Often represents investors in those sectors. Member of the National Association of Bond Lawyers. Member of Tennessee Association of Homes and Services for the Aging. Board member of Middle Tennessee Healthcare Executives Association.

Dick Cowart -- Baker, Donelson, Bearman & Caldwell
Expansive national health care practice. Merged his Jackson,
Miss. practice with Baker Donelson, now heads firm’s health care group. More visible locally through his writings and association memberships, but marshals Baker Donelson’s health care lawyers for clients he attracts. Huge rainmaker for the firm. Board member of the American Health Lawyers Association. President of the Southern Institute of Health Law. Authors health law articles for publications around the country.

Jay Hardcastle -- Boult, Cummings, Conners & Berry
Very active transactional practice. Presently heavily involved in the buying and selling of surgery centers. Often represents parties in hospital acquisitions and divestitures. Drafts physician contracts, advises tax-exempts, counsels hospitals in managed care contracting. Weighs in on regulatory matters, advises clients on Medicare and Medicaid issues. A former chair of Tennessee Bar Association’s health law section. Member of the National Health Lawyers Association.

Mark Manner -- Harwell, Howard, Hyne, Gabbert & Manner
A chemistry major in college, long interested in health care sciences. Active in corporate transactions and capital formation. One of few local lawyers to cover the biotechnology niche. Worked with BioMimetic Pharmaceuticals in its capital raising. Board member of Tennessee Biotechnology Association and Tennessee Technology Development Corp. A director of geneRx+ and Cleartrack Information Network. Managing partner of H3GM. Former antitrust attorney for U.S. Dept. of Justice.

Cindy Reisz -- Bass, Berry & Sims
Background as securities attorney helps in her counsel to fast-growing health care clients. Chairs firm’s health care practice. Past chair of Tennessee Bar Association’s health law section. Represents AmSurg. Helped American Healthways craft 10-year agreement with Blue Cross of Minnesota. Works with young companies: represents Surgical Alliance in plan for new rehab hospital and New Light Imaging Partners in new outpatient center. Active in initial public offerings, when public markets accommodate.

Joe Sowell -- Waller, Lansden, Dortch & Davis
Along with Reggie Hill and others, an important member of Waller’s large health care practice. Mostly involved in transactional matters concerning hospitals and surgery centers. Counsels on joint ventures between propriety and tax-exempts. Gained valuable hands-on experience as chief operating officer for Arcon, a mid-1990s company that developed ambulatory care centers. Assisted by his earlier studies for Master of Taxation at University of Florida.

John Titus -- Boult, Cummings, Conners & Berry
Broad corporate practice that now has heavy health care concentration, especially in the surgery center sector. Represents Surgis, the new surgery center company funded with $100 million from New Mountain Capital and led by ex-Phycor CEO Joe Hutts. Also has represented St. Thomas Health Services and Vanguard Healthcare LLC, the Brentwood-based nursing home and rehab company involved in project to build new East Nashville hospital. Experienced in public company matters.

John Voigt -- Sherrard & Roe
Four years leading Georgia Medical Care Foundation in mid-1970s conferred an understanding of the legal issues facing doctors. Since earning law degree in 1981, has become most effective agent on behalf of physicians. “If you’re a doctor trying to negotiate with a hospital, or trying to get in or to get out of a practice, you need to work with John.” Co-chairman of Tennessee Bar Association’s Health Law Forum 1990-1997. Wharton MBA, 1972.

Dan Warlick -- Warlick & Todd
Stays busy representing doctors brought before the Tennessee Board of Medical Examiners. Perfect counsel “if you’re a doctor in big trouble, could lose your license or go to jail, and need a flamboyant but effective lawyer.” Case in point, Dr. Charles Harlan, former state medical examiner frequently alleged with improprieties. Represented Harlan after he had a global positioning satellite device placed on ex-employee’s car. Counsel to Tammy Wynette daughters in getting singer’s body exhumed.

Immigration

Greg Siskind -- Siskind, Susser, Haas & Devine
Leads an immigration law firm with offices in 10 cities, including Beijing, Buenos Aires, Tijuana and Toronto. On employment-related issues, the best in town, even though he moved his residence to Memphis to be near the INS office and Immigration Court and commutes regularly to Nashville. Has a busy practice with local health care companies. Partner Marilyn Devine here covers family, asylum and deportation matters. National expert on use of the Internet by law firms.

Labor/Employment

Bob Ballow -- King & Ballow
At 71, one of the most respected corporate defense attorneys on labor matters in the country. Poster boy of organized labor public relations campaigns, which regularly call him “union busting.” Many media clients. Represented the San Francisco Chronicle in 1994 strike, and later after workers unionized. Also worked for management of the Chicago Tribune, and New York Daily News during its 1990-1991 strike. Was general counsel for International Circulation Managers Association. Bob Boston Waller, Lansden, Dortch & Davis Represents companies in labor/employment disputes, including claims of employment agreement breeches. Heads Waller Lansden’s dispute resolution group. Has represented public companies in defamation claims against anonymous online chat-room participants. Teaches and trains groups on labor law issues. Advises management on day-to-day employment matters. Board member of state Department of Labor & Workforce Development. NASD and NFA arbitrator.

Bob Boston -- Waller, Landsden, Dortch & Davis
Represents companies in labor/employment disputes, including claims of employment agreement breeches. Heads Waller Landen's dispute resolution group. Has represented public companies in defamation claims against anonymous online chat-room participants. Teaches and trains groups on labor law issues. Advises management on day-to-day employment matters. Board member of state Department of Labor & Workforce Development. NASD and NFA arbitrator.

Karen Ellis -- Bass, Berry & Sims
Typically represents employers, often large Fortune 500 companies, in employment-related litigation. A generalist in terms of industry focus, having represented health care, newspaper, restaurant, trucking and child care companies. Has defended against class-action race discrimination charges, including those brought by African-American employees and applicants against Toshiba’s Lebanon plant. A Fellow of the American College of Labor and Employment Lawyers.

Reid Estes -- Stewart, Estes & Donnell
Employment discrimination and violations of the Fair Labor Standards Act plaintiffs attorney. “Nationally recognized expert in wage and hour class-action litigation.” Led class-action against Shoney’s for deducting cash shortages from exempt managers and won $18 million settlement. Active in wage and hour litigation involving Krystal and Sbarro. Got $1.4 million settlement of racial discrimination claims against Toshiba. Argued ADA claim of dismissed Frito-Lay worker with spastic colon.

Eddie Wayland -- King & Ballow
Focuses mostly on labor law but receives most publicity for First Amendment cases. Aggressive and confident, “Eddie is hard-working—he insists on knowing the law and does not let others do his work.” Founder of the TBA Labor Letter. Represented Acuff-Rose in its 1992 copyright lawsuit against Luther Campbell and 2 Live Crew for “Oh, Pretty Woman” parody. Defended Sports Illustrated in Tex Cobb’s defamation suit, assisting Floyd Abrams in reversal of $8.5 million verdict.

Medical Malpractice - Defense

Steve Anderson -- Walker, Bryant, Tipps & Malone
At 38 years of age, the youngest lawyer on the list. Already has 14 years of trial experience, much of it defending against medical malpractice claims in the state and federal appeals courts. Understudy to powerful Bob Walker, accepting greater litigation responsibility. In December, won in state appeals court with the vacating of a $7.4 million medical malpractice verdict against Vanderbilt stemming from the hospital care given a drunk driver injured in a wreck.

Lee Barfield -- Bass, Berry & Sims
Possibly Bass’ strongest litigator, focusing on health care. Has been involved in many high-profile cases, including Bryant-Bruce v. Vanderbilt, successfully defending against allegations of wrongful reporting of child abuse. Won Caldararo v. Vanderbilt, key to juror information issues. Defeated suit claiming Metro Public Health Clinic caused blindness in a patient being treated for TB. Lead role in Brentwood Academy v. TSSAA that went to the U.S. Supreme Court.

C.J. Gideon -- Gideon & Wiseman
Extremely active medical malpractice defense practice, much of it representing claims that involve HCA hospitals, including Centennial Medical Center and Skyline. Also represents other health care providers. Author of “The Countersuit in Medical Malpractice” published in The Journal of the Tennessee Medical Association. Plenty of non-med mal work, including representing the Levine family in their suit against Perry March that resulted in $113.5 million jury verdict.

David King -- Bass, Berry & Sims
Young, not as heralded or experienced as partner Barfield, but increasingly accomplished defending hospitals, doctors and nurses in health care litigation. Litigation counsel for Vanderbilt University Medical Center and a large anesthesia group. National coordinating counsel for a long-term care chain’s professional liability and general liability claims. A member of the American Health Lawyers Association and the Defense Research Institute.

Noel Stahl -- Miller & Martin
Since a four-year stint as a staff attorney in the U.S. Marines, has focused on medical malpractice defense for 26 years. Has defended against numerous claims against doctors. Represents hospitals and their physician practitioners and nursing homes. Trial counsel to insurance companies and their insured physicians throughout Tennessee. Member of the International Association of Defense Counsel. Also defends self-insured organizations in product liability lawsuits.

Patents

Jack Waddey -- Waddey & Patterson
Leads Nashville’s only intellectual property boutique of any size, with eight registered patent attorneys. With aerospace engineering degree from Auburn, got gigs as an engineer with General Electric and a patent examiner for the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. Along with partner Wayne Beavers (former general counsel for Gibson Guitar), advises clients on trademark, patent and copyright matters. Also prosecutes violations of intellectual property.

Personal injury (Plaintiff)

John Branham -- Branham & Day
Originally very involved in insurance defense, though currently busier with plaintiff matters. Also provides legal malpractice defense work, as he did for the former Dearborn & Ewing law firm against charges stemming from advice on an investment plan. Theatrical, best suited to trials before juries who may respond emotionally. Former director of Nashville Bar Association. Elected Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers. Co-founded firm in 1992 with John Day, then of Boult Cummings.

John Day -- Branham & Day
One of the best personal injury lawyers in town, achieving notable judicial decisions, not just big awards. In Jordan v. Baptist Three Rivers Hospital, established award for loss of consortium to adult children of wrongful death victim. Later used this to score $6 million verdict in circuit court bench trial for loss of affection for family of stillborn baby. Got a slip-and-fall settlement from Wal-Mart, defeating its claim that unidentified person was responsible. Former head of state trial lawyers.

Randy Kinnard -- Kinnard, Clayton & Beveridge
Decorated Airborne Ranger in Vietnam, “his abilities are best attested to by the fear and hostility exhibited by the less self-assured in the local medical profession.” First name given by legal pros when asked for the best personal injury attorney in Nashville. Won $6.5 million for woman who suffered a brain injury after a tubal ligation. Reached settlement with Vanderbilt in 2001 for man whose penis was amputated after a faulty prostate procedure. President, Tennessee Trial Lawyers Association.

John Nolan - Solo practice
Forty years of experience as a litigator, mostly on behalf of plaintiffs. “He’s great.” Has the “ability to initiate and doggedly prosecute cases even when it is slow slogging.” “I would entrust my personal injury case without reservation” to Nolan. Has always shown the perseverance needed to succeed as a plaintiff attorney, in contrast to “some in town, who, while experienced and certainly talented, I would not count on to stay engaged until the conclusion when the going gets tough and a better case comes along.”

Charlie Williams -- Williams & Associates
Prolific plaintiffs attorney, reaching numerous settlements for victims of auto and tractor-trailer accidents, medical negligence, propane appliance explosions, inadequate security at hotels and shopping malls. He and partners have fourteen $1 million-plus settlements in past 10 years. Sued on behalf of woman unsuccessfully treated for back pain with orthopedic bone screws. Chief counsel and lead negotiator for the Fraternal Order of Police, 1977-1987.

Public Finance

Charlie Wray -- Bass, Berry & Sims
For past 25 years has focused on tax-exempt finance. Now shares public finance legal market with few others, namely Ogden Stokes (Stokes Bartholomew name partner who has represented the Metro Health and Educational Facilities Board since 1974). Frequent bond counsel to small industrial revenue bonds, sometimes backed by bank letters of credit. Bond counsel to waste disposal facility bonds for Eastman Chemical and DuPont. Works with 501(c)(3) organizations on their financings. Magna cum laude graduate of Harvard Law School.

Real Estate (Commercial)

Dewees Berry -- Bass, Berry & Sims
Veteran litigator on such real estate matters as eminent domain, contract disputes, mechanic’s liens. Has argued matters involving negligent impairment of security interests and property condemnations. Advises on zoning, planning and land use. Also has busy transactional practice, including the downtown Hard Rock Café, Thoroughbred Village in Cool Springs and the Metro Airport Business Center. President-elect of the Nashville Bar Association.

Richard Warren -- Boult, Cummings, Conners & Berry
nvolved in some of Nashville’s biggest commercial development projects. Represented Hines Interests in the 2525 West End Ave. office/retail building. Also involved in transactions for 3322 West End and the acquisition of AmSouth Center. In earlier days, did a lot of apartment and retail work for Jacques-Miller. Chairman of the American Bar Association’s Real Property Section’s Committee on Partnerships and Other Investment Vehicles. Chairman of Urban Housing Solutions nonprofit.

Real Estate (Residential)

George Mudter -- Mudter & Patterson
The Atlanta native and graduate of University of Georgia School of Law, along with partner Gerry Patterson, handles the lion’s share of upper-end residential real estate closings in Nashville. President of 23-year-old First Title and Escrow Co. Experienced and smart, can speedily work through the mounds of paperwork that accompany closings. Recommended by many leading local real estate brokers. Green Hills-based practice covers transactions, title insurance and mortgages.

Securities

Jim Cheek -- Bass, Berry & Sims
Most prolific, and by most accounts, the premiere securities lawyer in town for the past 25 years. Has represented more than 50 public companies in SEC and merger/acquisition matters. National reputation. As chair of the ABA’s task force on corporate responsibility, is drafting recommendations on companies’ internal corporate governance. Counsel to the independent directors of 130 Merrill Lynch mutual funds. Past chair of legal advisory boards of both the NYSE and NASDAQ.

Chase Cole -- Waller, Lansden, Dortch & Davis
Experienced in all aspects of securities work. Worked with LifePoint on its $200 million convertible subordinated note offering, Province on its $150 million note offering. Involved with Heavy Lift Helicopters/Sco-Mat Inc. merger. Represents Van Hedge Fund Advisors, Aveta Health. On ABA’s negotiated acquisitions and federal regulation of securities committees. Chairs Waller’s corporate governance task force. Chaired the 2002 Legal Aid Society of Middle Tennessee Annual Campaign.

Donald McKenzie -- Sherrard & Roe
Oversaw securities work at Gaylord Entertainment 1999-2001, including monetization of $600 million block of CBS stock from sale of TV station. Began practice in Rhodesia (now Zimbabwe). Focuses on mergers and acquisitions and securities. Teaches classes and seminars on structuring venture capital financing, and recently on business acquisitions in a down economy. A member of the International Bar Association, on international sales, trading and commercial transactions committees.

Brad Reed -- Bass, Berry & Sims
A dean of local securities attorneys. Now is known for his “private company divorce counsel,” such as resolving shareholder disputes in closely held organizations. Most assignments are quiet, rarely learned of by others. Represented the Jack Massey Foundation and Estate in Maryland Farms dispute. Other clients include the Christie Cookie Co. and the Junior League of Nashville. Chairman of the board of advisors at the Massey Graduate School of Business at Belmont University.

Mitch Walker -- Bass, Berry & Sims
Along with Jim Cheek, one of the most active locally in public stock offerings. Focuses on capital formation, corporate governance, mergers and acquisitions. Currently spearheads firm’s securities work for Gaylord Entertainment Co., handling the sale of Word to AOL Time Warner and sale of Acuff-Rose to Sony. Represents J. Alexander’s and Performance Food Group. Previously was kept busy leading the securitizations of Clayton Homes’ mobile home financings.

Social Security

Mike Williamson -- Solo practice
An attorney to turn to if your disability benefits under Social Security are being denied. Works on contingency. Appears before closed hearings of eight-judge panel in MetroCenter. “Mike is very dedicated. He accepts clients who can be sort of hard to deal with and provides some emotional support.” Influenced by Vandy Law’s Frank Bloch, steered away from 70-hour-a-week corporate practice. Now developing a practice in private sector long-term disability claims disputes.

Tax (Corporate)

Dick Barry -- Bass, Berry & Sims
Former trial attorney with the U.S. Department of Justice’s tax division in Washington, D.C. Now focuses on complex corporate transactions, sometimes weighs in to defend ERISA lawsuits. “Has an enormous command of corporate tax.” Counsels companies on best legal structure to gain tax advantages. Advises on qualified retirement plans and employee stock ownership plans. “Not a swashbuckler, very cautious.” Earned his ML degree in tax from Georgetown University.

Joe Gibbs -- Boult, Cummings, Conners & Berry
Broad range of tax work as head of Boult Cummings’ tax group. “An excellent tax attorney,” a fellow local tax lawyer says of the West Virginia native. Focuses on state and local taxation and attendant litigation. Frequently advises clients on tax consequences of real estate transactions and development. Has advised foreign nationals on the U.S. tax treatment of their U.S. investments. Past president of Paul J. Hartman State and Local Tax Forum.

Michael Hinchion -- Stites & Harbison
Began as a CPA, including a stint at Coopers & Lybrand. Still a member of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Earned an MBA from Indiana University in 1980. “His wealth of experience … gives him the ability to be very practical and offer ideas that make sense in addition to solving the legal problem at hand.” Practices in the areas of ERISA, tax and corporate law. Attorney since 1984 with Farris Warfield (merged into Stites in Jan. 2001).

Larry Thrailkill -- Thrailkill, Harris, Wood & Boswell
Focuses on advising the business interests of high net worth families. Has advised the Eddie DeBartolo family, for whose company he served as chief operating officer 1995-1998. He was president of DeBartolo’s San Francisco Forty Niners football team during the 1998 season. Has advised the Alvin Beaman family and is director of the family foundation. Also represented the Lindahl family, former owners of State Industries. “Represents big money people very quietly.”

Tax (Individual)

Mike Sontag -- Bass, Berry & Sims
Busy on both individual and corporate tax matters. Along with partner James Gooch, makes for a formidable tax combo. “Mike’s an animal on tax.” Earned LL.M. in tax at New York University School of Law. “Very smart in estate work.” On corporate side, has represented American Healthcorp and Envoy on spin-offs, and a subsidiary of Daily Mail on a $12 million tax refund. “One of the hardest working lawyers in town.” Former president of Tennessee Federal Tax Institute.

Trusts & Estates

James Gooch -- Bass, Berry & Sims
Over the past 30 years, has built the best book of trust and estate planning clients in the city. Began in the U.S. Army’s JAG Corp, then earned an LL.M. in tax from New York University. Relied upon by many of Nashville’s wealthiest families to handle their complex tax matters. A former president of the Tennessee Federal Tax Institute. A Fellow of the American College of Trust and Estate Counsel and a trustee of the Southern Federal Tax Institute.

Rick Holton -- Stokes, Bartholomew, Evans & Petree
Thirty-three years in tax and estate planning. “An experienced planner with a significant tax background, handling sophisticated planning.” Merged his seven-lawyer tax boutique with Stokes in 2001, now leads 20-person tax practice. “Great clientele of rich people.” A CPA and trust officer prior to entering law. “Has a lot of savvy about investments, in addition to tax law.” A director of the Nashville Symphony Association, Community Foundation, alumni boards of Vanderbilt undergraduate and law schools.

Mike Kaplan -- Sherrard & Roe
Very strong in estate planning and tax-exempt organizations, though a tax generalist. Counts many public charitable organizations and private foundations as clients. “In an arcane area of the law where many practitioners are on the dull side, Mike is a great personality.” Past president of the Tennessee Federal Tax Institute. Earned his LL.M. from New York University. Former chair of the Tennessee Bar Association’s Tax, Probate and Trust Law Section.

Utility Regulation

Henry Walker -- Boult, Cummings, Conners & Berry
The anti-BellSouth attorney. Thirteen years experience as general counsel to the state Public Service Commission (PSC). Now defends telecom companies depending on and competing with BellSouth, often in front of PSC successor, the Tennessee Regulatory Authority (TRA). Represents southeastern carriers who oppose BellSouth’s entry into long distance service and resellers in disputes with BellSouth. Won interest on refunds BellSouth owed payphone owners. Harvard Law grad.

Chuck Welch -- Farris, Mathews, Branan, Bobango & Hellen
Represents Time Warner Telecom before the TRA in its struggles with BellSouth. Also serves NewSouth Communications, Business Telecom and Level 3 before state agencies. A registered lobbyist for Advanced Protective Services, the City of Chattanooga and Memphis Basketball Partners. Former assistant attorney in Shelby County and assistant city attorney in Colliervsille. Has represented waste companies, such as HC Sewage Treatment in its efforts to build a small treatment center in Hampton, Tenn.

Zoning/Land Use

Bill Farmer -- Farmer & Luna
Heavy government experience as an assistant U.S. attorney and federal public defender, and as chairman of the Tennessee Valley Authority Land Commission since 1985. Former law partner of Mayor Bill Purcell. “If you’re not a litigator, you need connections to get deals done. Farmer’s very connected to a lot of people.” Land condemnation matters are one area of focus. Generally emphasizes commercial, tort, probate and criminal litigation. Chairman of Father Ryan High School.

J.W. Luna -- Farmer & Luna
Known for a good relationship with the Corps of Engineers, which has say over river-area development. Very well connected as a result of having held three cabinet posts under McWherter. Helped create state Department of Environment and Conservation, then served as its commissioner. Leverages environmental and government experience. Has represented pipeline companies, roadbuilders, developers. A director of the Land Trust for Tennessee.

Tom White -- Tune, Entrekin & White
Always the first call for developers at the first inkling of zoning or land use problems. Seeped into the public consciousness with his successful actions to defend Hoover Inc.’s efforts to develop a rock quarry. In the news more recently for efforts to push forward road projects stymied by Native American remains and in representing Ensworth’s plans to build a high school adjacent to Warner Park. Has represented state homebuilders group since 1970s.

We invite you to share your opinions of "Best Lawyers in Nashville" with us. All info will be on background (unless specified otherwise) and used to improve next year's list. Email fox@nashvillepost.com.