Fernandez-Vargas v. Gonzales Immigration Case To Be Decided By Supreme Court
The
Supreme Court is currently hearing the case of Fernandez-Vargas v. Gonzales to
determine if a law passed by congress in 1996 can be applied retroactively to
immigrants. The legislation passed
by congress and enacted a year later in 1997 eliminated court hearings for
individuals for individuals who had previously been deported.
Fernandez-Vargas entered reentered the US
prior to the law being written in 1996 but was deported without a
hearing. Lawyers on Vargas' side
claim that he should be exempt from the law since he entered the United States
prior to its creation.
Until
this point, courts have been split on the issue.
While the 6th and
9th Circuit
Courts have sided with Fernandez-Vargas on the legal dispute, the 10th Circuit
Court sided with the government. The
US government defends their position by pointing to the nature and intent of the
law. According to Thomas Burr of The
Salt Lake Tribune, Congress made it clear that the law should apply to all
immigrants, regardless of when they reentered the country.
Fernandez-Vargas'
case is could affect thousands of immigrants who have reentered the country
after previously being deported. If
Fernandez-Vargas loses his case, then those individuals who reentered the
country prior to 1997 will be subject to the same deportation procedures as
Vargas.
Disclaimer: This newsletter is provided as a public service and not intended to establish an attorney client relationship. Any reliance on information contained herein is taken at your own risk.