Passage of Border Bill Swift But Measure Not Likely to Become Law
The
House of Representatives acted with extraordinary speed in passing one of the
toughest immigration bills since the National Origin Act of 1924. The bill, H.R.
4337, was introduced by House Judiciary Committee Chairman James Sensenbrenner
on December 6th, passed through the Judiciary Committee on December
13th and passed the entire House of Representatives just four days
later. Many members who voted on the 169 page piece of legislation may not have
even had the opportunity to review the bill before casting a vote.
The
bill passed by a margin of 239 to 182 largely along party lines. Republicans
supported the measure by a margin of 203 to 17. Democrats opposed by a margin of
164 to 36. The bill’s extreme measures and its failure to include guest worker
provisions make it highly unlikely that it will pass the Senate. However,
pro-immigration advocates worry that many of the bill’s most controversial
provisions could make it into a final bill that eventually reaches the
President’s desk.
H.R.
4337 is more than 200 pages long and has dozens of sections. Among the more
controversial are provisions calling for
-
making
it a felony punishable by at least a year in prison to be in the
-
expanding
the definition of alien smuggling to include support offering any kind of
support including the kind of aid offered by church groups and social service
agencies
-
elimination
of the annual green card lottery
-
a
provision giving state and local law enforcement officials inherent authority to
enforce immigration law
-
the
construction of more than 700 miles of fencing along the Mexican border and a
study of whether the
-
elimination
of judicial review for most types of cases including non-immigrant visas and
arbitrary motion to reopen denials
-
makes
it an aggravated felony to use a
false passport even if used as a way to get to the
-
Makes a
single drunk driving offense a ground for deportation
Despite
the swift movement of the bill, numerous groups publicly opposed the measure
including most of the major religious faiths in the
The
bill may also have a damaging effect on US-Mexico relations. Mexican President
Vicente Fox, according to today’s New York Times, is furious about the passage
of the bill, calling it a “shameful” setback in bilateral relations and a
troubling reflection of
Fox
went further stating “To us, what has been decided in the United States
Congress is a terrible sign that does not speak well for a country that calls
itself a country of migrants. The entire population of the
According
to the Times, Ruben Aguilar, a spokesman for Fox, said Mexico feels they trusted
President Bush to get support form his own party for a more comprehensive
immigration bill and they are “deeply disappointed” by the House bill.
Disclaimer: This newsletter is provided as a public service and not intended to establish an attorney client relationship. Any reliance on information contained herein is taken at your own risk.